diff --git a/osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch/UI/Catcher.cs b/osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch/UI/Catcher.cs
index ab754e51f7..f77dab56c8 100644
--- a/osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch/UI/Catcher.cs
+++ b/osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch/UI/Catcher.cs
@@ -418,10 +418,13 @@ namespace osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch.UI
 
         private void clearPlate(DroppedObjectAnimation animation)
         {
-            var droppedObjects = caughtObjectContainer.Children.Select(getDroppedObject).ToArray();
+            var caughtObjects = caughtObjectContainer.Children.ToArray();
 
             caughtObjectContainer.Clear(false);
 
+            // Use the already returned PoolableDrawables for new objects
+            var droppedObjects = caughtObjects.Select(getDroppedObject).ToArray();
+
             droppedObjectTarget.AddRange(droppedObjects);
 
             foreach (var droppedObject in droppedObjects)
@@ -430,10 +433,10 @@ namespace osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch.UI
 
         private void removeFromPlate(CaughtObject caughtObject, DroppedObjectAnimation animation)
         {
-            var droppedObject = getDroppedObject(caughtObject);
-
             caughtObjectContainer.Remove(caughtObject, false);
 
+            var droppedObject = getDroppedObject(caughtObject);
+
             droppedObjectTarget.Add(droppedObject);
 
             applyDropAnimation(droppedObject, animation);
@@ -456,6 +459,8 @@ namespace osu.Game.Rulesets.Catch.UI
                     break;
             }
 
+            // Define lifetime start for dropped objects to be disposed correctly when rewinding replay
+            d.LifetimeStart = Clock.CurrentTime;
             d.Expire();
         }